July 29

How can employers ensure there is mutual respect in the workplace?

On and off social media platforms, the debate on sex and gender has become polarised. According to the government’s tribunal decisions portal, there have been 14 decisions in the space of less than two years, and several of them have made national news headlines.

The most prominent of these cases was an award of more than £100,000 against an organisation which was found to have unlawfully discriminated against an individual after it did not offer her an employment contract or renew her visiting fellowship because she had expressed gender-critical views on her Twitter account. Later prominent cases include that of a barrister who won a case against her employer, after losing work due to her involvement with the LGB Alliance Group.

Tribunal’s advice

But it was an instruction by the judge in the recent case of a social worker who was suspended and subjected to a long disciplinary process by both her employer and her professional regulator for sharing a link to a petition to the International Olympic Committee that male athletes should not compete in female sports, as well as another petition on women’s rights to sex-based protections, such as female-only hospital wards, that should prompt employers to consider how they deal with contentious beliefs at work.

The tribunal found that the nature of the disciplinary process constituted harassment, ruling that her social media posts “fell within her protected rights for freedom of thought and freedom to manifest her beliefs as protected under Articles 9 and 10 of the Human Rights Act”. Compensation was awarded and the judge ordered all managers and HR staff in both organisations to receive training on the freedom of expression and protected belief.

Contentious issue

One of the reasons that compensation was so high in this case was the fact that the employer “should have known better” in the light of these recent decisions. The rise in claims like these shows that more and more beliefs are being deemed as worthy of protection under the Equality Act – and inevitably, if more beliefs and rights are protected, that raises the potential for those thought systems to come into conflict.

The way the Equality Act is drafted leaves it open that many types of belief are worthy of protection, as long as they meet the five-step test that shows they meet the requirement as follows:

• the belief must be genuinely held.
• it must be a belief and not simply an opinion or viewpoint based on the present state of information available.
• it must be a belief as to a weighty and substantial aspect of human life and behaviour.
• it must attain a certain level of cogency, seriousness, cohesion and importance.
• it must be worthy of respect in a democratic society, be not incompatible with human dignity and not conflict with the fundamental rights of others.

Difficult balance

The biggest lesson that should be taken from the most recent cases is that when it comes to the contentious debate over gender identity, employers need to think in terms of balancing conflicting rights, rather than viewing their role as protecting one group (those with the protected characteristic of gender reassignment) from discrimination by another (those with gender critical views).

Stay neutral

So for an employer celebrating LGBTQ staff or hosting a Pride march, could it be argued that supporting staff with gender-critical beliefs goes against those efforts? Can an employer celebrate different identities without aggrieving others? It’s more of a tightrope than before – as an employer you must try to avoid being seen to be in one camp or another, to be taking sides.

The recent decisions make it clear that someone can hold a gender-critical belief but this does not mean people could be transphobic or misgender people. The key is to have a framework where people know they will be treated with dignity and respect even if their belief comes into conflict with those of someone else. A balanced approach is essential.

Expressing a view is lawful provided that the manner in which it is expressed does not cross the line into harassment or discrimination. It does not matter if that view is unfashionable, unpopular or considered by some to be objectionable, as long as no harassment or discrimination arises.

Training and culture

Training can be a good opportunity to engage with employees in how to foster a non-discriminatory work culture – for example, training on unconscious bias is underutilised but can provide individuals with personal insight about how we make judgments about others and how to prevent discrimination. Organisations play a critical role in creating a culture where it’s okay to discuss beliefs in an open and sensitive manner but understand that all opinions are valid.

Employers should advise employees as to their internal processes for raising any concerns and the support that will be given to them, with a view to resolving issues in a collaborative way. Employers should also make employees aware of their expectations with regard to discussion of sensitive topics and the potential consequence for engaging in such debate.

Looking forward

A further consideration is that, from October this year, employers will come under an obligation to prevent workers from harassment under the Worker Protection Act, so it is important to remind staff of what is acceptable. This new law carries with it a potential 25% uplift in compensation at tribunal, so these policies should not just be in a handbook on a shelf, but managers should be reminding staff about their obligations to be respectful.

However, the recent decisions in gender-critical cases could result in a decline in their frequency because it is increasingly clear to employers that such beliefs are protected. The law is clear that so-called ‘gender-critical’ beliefs are protected provided they are contained within a reasonable expression. Harassment continues to be outlawed but as with nearly all cases about belief, the outcome will very much depend on the particular facts.

Please email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917878384 for any advice or assistance.

July 3

What does a Labour win mean for employment?

The Labour Party has ambitious plans for reforming employment law. It has promised to introduce legislation on its New Deal for Working People within the first 100 days of a new Labour government. This means by 12 October 2024, assuming Labour wins the general election on 4 July 2024.

This doesn’t mean that new laws will be in place by 12 October 2024. It just means that Labour is committing to start the process as quickly as it can.

So how quickly might the New Deal be implemented?

Unless and until Labour publishes more details, nobody can say with any certainty what’s going to be implemented when but here are some thoughts on possible timelines.

Possible quick wins for Labour – from 5 July 2024 to April 2025

National Living Wage.

Labour has pledged that:

1. the NLW will take account of the cost of living; and
2. that the 18-20 age band will be removed.

Labour could set the new remit immediately on coming into government and ensure that a new cost-of-living-sensitive minimum wage takes effect from April 2025. Labour could abolish the 18-20 age band at the same time although it might choose to delay that additional change, which could have a significant effect on businesses employing younger workers, pending further consultation.

Tips Act.

The new Tips Act – requiring employers to pass 100% of tips to workers – has already received Royal Assent and was expected to come into force on 1 October 2024. Labour has pledged to strengthen the law to ensure workers receive their tips in full. This is an easy win for Labour, since it involves simply enacting legislation that is already in place.

Statutory sick pay reforms.

Labour has promised to remove the need to wait until day four to receive SSP and the requirement to earn above the lower earnings limit to qualify.
Both changes require primary legislation and are expected to be made via the Employment Rights Bill. It is just about possible that these changes could be made in April 2025, as they won’t require any substantial follow-up regulations to bring them in.

Trade Union law repeals.

Labour has pledged to change the law around trade unions in several ways. This includes:

• repealing certain anti-strike laws including, for example, the laws around minimum service levels during public sector strikes.

These repeals seem likely to take effect instantly when the Employment Rights Bill receives Royal Assent.

Day 1 parental/paternity leave

• Labour has promised “day 1 parental leave”. It’s unclear if this means parental leave within the strict (limited) legal meaning of that term, or any kind of right for parents to take family leave.
• Parental leave (the right to take up to 18 weeks’ unpaid leave until a child is 18) currently has a one-year qualifying period, which could be scrapped relatively easily using powers in existing legislation (but this type of leave is hardly ever used).
• Paternity leave (the right to take paid time off around the birth or within the first year) currently requires six months’ employment and Labour could also scrap this under existing powers.

It’s therefore conceivable that these reforms could happen very quickly, although much depends on how much consultation Labour plans to do first.

Predictable Terms Act

The Predictable Terms Act gives workers the right to request (but not to have) a more predictable contract. It has already received Royal Assent but needs accompanying regulations to bring it into force. It was expected to come into force in September.

The Act falls a long way short of delivering what Labour wants to achieve for zero-hours workers, but it’s conceivable that Labour could choose to bring it into force as a stepping stone on the way to further reform.

Key priorities – within two years

1. Right not to be unfairly dismissed from day 1.

This is one of Labour’s headline proposals and we can reasonably expect it to be a priority. In theory, Labour could achieve this almost immediately. In practice, however, this proposal is likely to be subject to extensive consultation particularly as to the new rules that are likely to be needed for dismissals during probationary periods, and an implementation period.

It will also require an updated (or new) Acas Code of Practice, which will need to be consulted on. It seems most likely that this will take effect in October 2025 or April 2026 at the earliest.

2. Bereavement leave.

We would expect the Employment Rights Bill to make provision for bereavement leave, but secondary legislation might be needed to bring the right into effect so this could take up to two years.

3. Zero-hours contracts, right to contract based on average hours.

Labour has made banning “exploitative” zero-hours contracts and creating a right to a contract based on average working hours one of its flagship proposals.

We would expect the Employment Rights Bill to include provision for this. It’s very unclear, however, how these new rights will operate in practice. Substantial consultation and secondary legislation will almost certainly be needed. It’s possible that new rights could take effect within the first two years but in practice this may be ambitious.

Longer term – not until towards the end of a first term of government

1. Single worker status.

Labour has said that it will carry out a full and detailed consultation on its plans to move towards a single worker status. This is an extremely complex and difficult subject to legislate on, so it may be that any changes will only take effect towards the end of a Labour government’s first term in office.

2. Single enforcement body.

The Employment Rights Bill is likely to create this body, but as it seems inevitable that there will need to be extensive consultation about its remit, powers, staffing and funding, it may be years before it is fully up and running.

3. Expansion of pay gap reporting.

Labour’s plans to introduce ethnicity pay gap and disability pay gap reporting are also likely to take some time to implement in practice.

4. Reform of family leave framework.

Labour has suggested that it will review the family leave framework within the first year of coming into government. In the absence of any specific proposals at this stage substantial reforms are likely to be a long way off – not until the end of a first term in government at the earliest.

Conclusion

Employers should not worry too much about significant changes being rushed in by the end of this calendar year, despite all the talk of the first 100 days. Employment law reform takes time. The direction of travel is clear, though, so if Labour does win the election, we are going to see very significant reforms sooner or later.

For any advice do email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

Copyright © 2024 GoodHR Ltd All rights reserved.
Registered in England no. 8408047

www.goodhr.co.uk
nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk
Tel. 44(0)7917 878384

unsubscribe from this list update subscription preferences

June 5

Can employers insist that their staff return to the office….?

Sir Jim Ratcliffe, the co-owner of Manchester United football club, has stated that employees who are not willing to come to the club’s premises to work should seek ¬‘alternative employment.’

Ratcliffe, who also owns the chemicals giant Ineos, said that productivity falls when people work from home. He cited a 20% drop in email traffic at one of his companies when it trialled work-from-home Fridays.

Since the Covid pandemic, Manchester United has had a flexible work-from-home policy but at a staff meeting held in person and online video last week he announced a reversal of this and told employees: “If you don’t like it, please seek ¬alternative employment.” He said working together in person would strengthen unity and collaboration.

With 4 in 10 companies returning to a full-time office week in 2023, the Great Office Return appears to be continuing in 2024 as the Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday Era slowly dwindles.

Trying to get employees to step back into an office sparks mixed emotions. These differing attitudes on remote working can cause employees to quickly divide into camps of pro-home and pro-office.

The balance between the normalisation of working from home during COVID and the increase in loneliness amongst remote workers can be a tricky balancing act for recruiters and HR teams.

Whilst it is very unlikely all staff will be going back to the office full-time, businesses making plans to increase office time are best to develop clear and fair policies to avoid employee friction.

Can an employer ask an employee to return to the office?

Employers are entitled to ask employees to return to work to their normal place of work as a “reasonable management request” if the original employment contract specified that the employee would be office-based and no longer-term change was agreed.

Unfortunately, if clear parameters about expectations and contractual obligations were not set out at the outset, it may be difficult to force an employee to return to the office by relying on a contractual term.

Potential legal issues of making staff return to office working

There may be legal issues if working from home or hybrid working was contractually agreed with employees. It may also have become an implied term of their employment. Employers will then need to consider whether contracts and/or policies need changing under a formal process.

Can an employee request hybrid working?

A request for employees to return to their place of work may lead to an increase in flexible working requests under the Employment Relations (Flexible Working) Act, new regulations in force from 6 April 2024.

The new regulations include provisions for hybrid working as a definition of flexible working and allow employees to make a request from day one and up to two requests per year. Employers are required to consider all requests in an open-minded conversation with the employee about what flexible working arrangements might be possible.

Can an employer refuse a request for hybrid working?

An employer does not have to necessarily agree to the request (the business reasons for refusal remain the same under the new regulations).

However, refusing flexible working requests for hybrid or home working has risks for the employer and may give rise to grievances, claims for constructive unfair dismissal or a breach of flexible working legislation. It is important that employers treat similar requests in the same way to avoid complaints of unfairness and discrimination claims where an employee has a protected characteristic. Employers should therefore keep a record of all flexible working requests, responses and reasons given to assist in decision making.

Carrots (within reason) may be more effective than sticks!

Mandating employees to return to the office can result in unhappiness, resignations and overall reduced employee loyalty and so employers may be wise to consider a carrot approach – within reason.

Employers are noticing that with mixed emotions and outside pressures, some employees are reluctant to return to the office, whilst others are eagerly embracing returning to their office.

Here are a few examples of encouraging staff to come back into the office:

• offer in-person professional development
• set up in-person social and learning opportunities
• create meaningful team building activities
• offer transport subsidies
• encourage use of EAP programmes

Further, when considering a strategy to get employees back to office, employers need to consider the following:

1. increases in commuting costs
2. travel disruptions and strikes
3. increase in childcare costs
4. flexibility for personal schedules in family time, exercise classes or simple errands.

A balance should be made between employers’ and employees’ needs as ignoring either is likely to result in an unwelcomed response, and possible claims of discrimination arising.

For assistance with a hybrid working policy or any questions on this topic do email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

May 13

How will you embrace Mental Health Awareness Week?

And how will you prioritise employee mental health more generally in 2024……?

Mental Health Awareness Week 2024 will take place from 13 – 19 May 2024 and the theme is: “Movement: Moving more for our mental health” ie: helping people to find moments for movement in their daily routine whether at work or at home.

Mental health, now more than ever before, is increasingly becoming a key focus for inclusion and diversity.

Recruitment and retention

We know that employee turnover has a significant impact on the company bottom line. It’s important to understand the impact of the shift in our intergenerational workforce, younger generations in particular are becoming more aware and vocal in their focus on workplace wellbeing as a key factor that draws them to and keeps them in roles.

Company leaders focusing on employee well-being and incorporating better work practices will reduce the turnover in their industries, simultaneously fast-tracking business growth.

Impact on productivity and feelings towards work

When our wellbeing is chronically being impacted or there are enduring influences on employee mental health, there is a clear correlation in apathy, lack of productivity, and even feelings of resentment. In spaces where mental health is not prioritised we continue to see increased instances of absenteeism.

There is often a misplaced focus on “happy” workplaces as a solution, whereas our focus should be on healthy workplaces. When the focus is on fostering a sense of belonging, purpose, and fulfilment among employees, these inherently lead to enhanced well-being and job satisfaction.

Build understanding to reduce mental health discrimination

Multiple factors may combine, through our lives, to protect or undermine our mental health, and shift our position on the mental health spectrum. Individual psychological and biological factors such as emotional skills, substance use and genetics can make people more vulnerable to mental health problems.

It is only through taking a learned and strategic approach to understanding employee mental health that we can begin to foster inclusion and mitigate mental health discrimination.

A bespoke approach to training as well as creating opportunities for key skills such as Mental Health First Aid creates a culture of resilience and sustainability.

Ways to prioritise and support employee mental health:

Have key policies and procedures in place

Policies and procedures that are prepared with a high level of expertise form the foundations of prioritising mental health support in the workplace – evidenced in all key policies including mental health and wellbeing, sickness, and flexible working.

Ensure that polices and procedures are clear, accessible and indicate clearly the company’s prioritisation of employee mental health and wellbeing. Provide appropriate training for all people across the organisation.

To ensure that employees receive comprehensive support, catering to their diverse needs and enhancing not only job satisfaction but overall life satisfaction, it’s important to implement targeted and appropriate training for all people across the organisation.

Create psychologically safe workplaces

Having a culture of true psychological safety is the foundation that prioritising employee mental health is built on. Empathetic leadership that embeds inclusive values in word and practice allows for space to be both vulnerable and soft, and, dynamic and strong – by doing so, you pave the way for longevity and innovation.

Staff networks

Staff networks, employee resource groups, or ad-hoc employee support groups are a highly beneficial tool for embedding a culture of wellbeing within the workplace.

They show a recognition of the correlation between employee wellbeing and organisational success, fostering an environment where employee health and welfare are considered integral to business objectives. Through these networks organisations acknowledge the integral role of community support when it comes to employee wellbeing. These spaces provide agency where employees are empowered to take the lead on their wellbeing needs, with organisations providing the necessary resources, support, and flexibility to facilitate these spaces.

This approach not only enhances the relevance and effectiveness of wellbeing initiatives but also fosters a sense of autonomy and control among employees, contributing to improved wellbeing outcomes.

Summary

Prioritising employee mental health is not just a nice to have, it is business critical – incorporating an informed and robust culture of prioritising mental health takes an active and ongoing stance – through strategy, training and inclusive practice.

For help with policies or the implementation of a Mental Health and Wellbeing Audit please get in touch with nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

April 11

Paternity leave rules have changed….

New parents will have more flexibility to choose when to take statutory paternity leave under changes applying from April 2024.

Under the current rules, new dads and partners can take up to two weeks’ statutory paternity leave on the birth of their child. This is paid at a statutory rate of £172.48 each week. Leave must be taken in the first eight weeks and has to be taken as a single chunk of either one or two weeks. To be eligible for leave and pay, employees need six months’ continuous service. Statutory paternity leave is also available to the second person adopting a child (with the primary adopter being eligible for adoption leave).

The rules around how and when statutory paternity leave can be taken are now being relaxed.

What is changing with paternity leave?

Under the new rules, employees will be able to take statutory paternity leave at any point in the first year (up from the first eight weeks) and will be able to split it up into two separate blocks of one week (rather than having to take two weeks together).

This means that a new parent will be able to take statutory paternity leave in a variety of new ways, for example:

• one week when the baby is born and a second week after nine months when their partner returns to work; or
• no leave when the baby is born, but two weeks after 10 months.

The notice requirements are also changing. Currently, employees must give notice of their leave dates 15 weeks before the birth. This is changing so that dads/partners will only have to give 28 days’ notice of the leave they intend to take, although notice of entitlement must still be given 15 weeks before birth.

Finally, there is a tougher regime for declaring entitlement. Under the current rules, employers can ask the employee to sign a declaration that they are an eligible parent and that they want the leave for legitimate purposes (to care for the child or support their partner). The new rules say that employees must declare their eligibility and the legitimate purpose of their leave.

What is not changing with paternity leave?

The purpose of the leave : The purpose of the leave must still be for the employee to care for the child or support their partner. This remains likely to be interpreted broadly, but a new dad cannot, for example, take paternity leave to go on holiday without the baby.

Statutory paternity pay will go up slightly in April 2024, to £184.03, in line with the usual practice of uprating statutory payments. There are no plans to significantly improve on this low level of payment. Employers may choose to offer full pay (and many do) but, where employers do not top up pay, parents are generally better off taking holiday instead.

No right to postpone leave : Employers have no right to postpone statutory paternity leave or request that it be taken at a different time. This makes perfect sense for leave taken at the time of birth or adoption, since the employee cannot control those dates and the employer cannot reasonably argue over them. The lack of any employer say over the days will continue, however, when the rules change and the window in which leave can be taken significantly increases. This means that eligible employees will be able to take statutory paternity leave at dates of their choosing at any point in the first year, as of right, even if the dates are inconvenient for the employer. In this one respect, therefore, taking paternity leave differs from booking holiday.

Use paternity leave before shared parental leave : Statutory paternity leave is not available if the employee has already taken shared parental leave. Employees therefore need to have used up paternity leave before taking shared parental leave. This rule is also staying put and may become more significant when the rules change and employees become entitled to take paternity leave during the whole of the first year.

Finally, statutory paternity leave must still be taken in whole weeks.

When do the changes to paternity leave take effect?

The new rules apply to babies expected to be born after 6 April 2024 and to children expected to be placed for adoption on or after 6 April 2024.

What do employers need to do?

Employers may need to update their paternity leave policies, and people managers may need updating on the new rights.

From a practical perspective, once the new rules take effect, employers could experience a small uptick in employees taking statutory paternity leave, especially when employees want to avail themselves of the right to take their chosen dates without risk of cancellation. The overall impact is, however, likely to be modest given that the overall entitlement remains just two weeks and statutory payment remains low.

Employers should also consider what level of payment they want to make for statutory paternity leave as a matter of policy. Offering full pay is increasingly the norm.

Looking further forward, the Labour Party has indicated that it could scrap the six months’ service currently required to qualify for statutory paternity leave, so further change may lie ahead under a change of government.

For help with a new paternity policy please email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

March 18

New carers’ rights from 6 April 2024

From 6 April 2024, employees will have a statutory right to a week’s unpaid leave to care for a dependant.

Who can take carer’s leave?

Carer’s leave will apply to employees and is intended to allow the individual to provide or arrange care for a dependant with a long-term care need.
The definition of “dependant” mirrors the definition used for the right to time off for dependants. This includes a:

• spouse
• civil partner
• child
• parent
• a person who lives in the same household as the employee (other than by reason of them being their employee, tenant, lodger or boarder) or
• the wider catch-all provision, of a person who reasonably relies on the employee for care.

Employees are entitled to carer’s leave from day one of their employment. As with other statutory leave entitlements, employers cannot penalise any employee choosing to take advantage of carer’s leave once it is brought into force. Dismissal of an employee for a reason connected with their taking carer’s leave will be automatically unfair. Employees are also entitled to return to the same job they were doing immediately before they took carer’s leave.

What will carer’s leave be used for?

A “long-term care need” is defined as:

• an illness or injury (either physical or mental) that requires or is likely to require care for more than three months
• a disability under the Equality Act 2010 or
• issues related to old age.

How much time can be taken?

The entitlement to one week’s leave is the maximum any employee is entitled to. Employers are not able to require an employee to evidence their entitlement to the leave.

How can carer’s leave be taken?

Flexibly, with the key procedural requirements as follows:

• Employees using the leave must take a minimum of half a working day at a time; a working day meaning the employee’s usual working pattern. There is no need for the leave to be used on consecutive days either. Employees could therefore take five separate days over a 12-month rolling period.

• Employees are required to provide notice, although this does not need to be in writing. The notice must include the fact that the employee is entitled to take carer’s leave and the day(s) or part of a day that will be taken.

• Employees will be required to give notice which is either twice the length of time being requested, or three days, whichever is the longest. It is open to employers to waive the notice requirement provided the employee is otherwise eligible to take carer’s leave.

Does an employer have to agree?

Employers are not able to deny an employee’s request for carer’s leave but can postpone it if they reasonably consider that the operation of the business would be unduly disrupted if the leave was approved.

If the employer does postpone the leave, they must provide a written counter notice within seven days of the request, explaining the reason for the postponement and the revised dates the leave can be taken on. The employee must be allowed to take the requested leave within a month of their original request.

What remedies does an employee have if these rights are not upheld?

An employee will be able to bring an employment tribunal claim if their employer has unreasonably postponed, prevented or attempted to prevent them from taking carer’s leave. A tribunal can make a declaration and award compensation. Compensation is subject to what the tribunal considers “just and equitable”, taking into account the employer’s behaviour and any consequential loss sustained by the employee.

Practical implications for employers

Employers should start to consider:

• updating or creating policies to inform employees of the new right and the logistics of requesting and taking it.

• creating a “self-certification” form for employees to complete, declaring that they meet the legal definition of a carer and will be using the leave in that capacity.

• introducing a system of record-keeping to track the number of days taken. Employers should also use this data to consider what further support they could provide for employees (for example, allowing additional unpaid time off if staff are using high levels of annual leave to provide intermittent care or help to dependants).

• informing people managers of the new right, the fact that any dismissal connected to using the leave will be automatically unfair, and the potential sensitivities around this topic. Some employees may not wish their colleagues to be aware they are taking time off for caring responsibilities, if they have not previously discussed this at work, or may not want to inform their manager of their need to take carer’s leave.

Should I enhance this right?

Some employers may wish to enhance these new rights by:

• offering pay for some or all of an employee’s entitlement or
• offering an increased amount of unpaid time off.

This might be part of a package of measures designed to attract and retain older workers.

Even if employers do not intend to offer paid leave, the new right may encourage employees to talk to their employer about any caring responsibilities they have and how they are managing those responsibilities alongside work, and this in turn may lead to more employers adopting carer policies.

For assistance with a carers policy or updating existing policies, please email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +447917878384

March 4

Help for employers with the new flexible working laws….

The government has announced that the new flexible working regulations will come into effect on 6 April 2024, giving employees the right to request flexible working arrangements from day one of employment – under current law the right is only available after at least 26 weeks of employment.

‘Flexible working’ can refer to working patterns or hours including part time, flexi-time, term time, compressed hours and adjusting start and finish times, as well as location, for example, working from home.

What are the new regulations on flexible working?

• the right is available to employees from day one of employment
• employers will be required to consult with the employee when they make a flexible working request before rejecting it
• employers have to respond to a request within two months (it is currently three months)
• employees will be able to make two requests within a 12-month period, compared to the single request they are currently allowed
• employees are no longer required to explain what effect their request will have on the business.

Employers should review current policies…

To prepare for these changes, employers should start by reviewing their current flexible working policies and ensuring they align with the new regulations. They should also anticipate a higher volume of flexible working requests.

Employers should also ensure they have in place effective processes to review and respond to applications promptly and have trained their managers on how to deal with them too.

Embrace a shift in workplace dynamics…

Employers need to try and view the changes as an opportunity to reassess and enhance their operational models. It’s not just about complying with the law but embracing a shift in workplace dynamics that can lead to increased employee engagement, retention and a wider talent pool.

Businesses need to think about the broader implications of flexible working for their organisational culture which includes the following:

• investing in technology that supports remote or hybrid work
• redesigning workspaces to accommodate flexible schedules.

Give employees clarity…

Although employees will be granted the right to request flexible working from day one, there is no guarantee that these requests for flexible working will be granted.

Employees who rely on flexible working need to know when they apply for a role if the level of flexibility that they require can be met. Clarity in job adverts is essential – this is the only way for jobseekers to identify companies that can accommodate their working preferences. It’s also the best way for employers to find staff who will genuinely thrive in the working environment they offer.

Find a way to make requests work…

Not all roles are going to be suitable for every requested working pattern but approaching any requests from the point of view of ‘how could we make this work’ is a good starting point.

Accommodating flexible working patterns will only benefit employers because employees are increasingly looking for businesses to work for that value wellbeing as part of their culture, and flexible working opportunities have become a staple incentive to attract the best people.

Businesses should consider alternatives if employees request a pattern that does not work for them. There are eight fair reasons for refusing flexible working requests and employers should think about the impact on the business of accepting or rejecting flexible working requests.

You will need a newly drafted flexible working policy….

For assistance with a newly drafted flexible working policy, which needs to be significantly different to the current policies, please email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +447917878384

February 22

Are you aware that you may be obliged to make reasonable adjustments where a worker’s menopausal symptoms amount to a disability….?

Recent research has found that one in ten women who worked during the menopause had to leave their job because of their symptoms or because they didn’t feel ‘safe’ enough to request the workplace adjustments.

The Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) has emphasised the need for an employer to make reasonable adjustments where a worker’s menopause symptoms amount to a disability.

What is a disability?

The EHRC states that menopause symptoms – which can range from hot flushes to sleep problems – can be considered a disability if they have a long-term and substantial impact on a woman’s ability to carry out normal daily activities.

Employer’s legal obligation

Employers have a legal obligation to make reasonable adjustments in the case of a disability, and they must ensure they do not directly or indirectly discriminate against a woman – or any employee – because of a disability.

Reasonable adjustments for menopausal symptoms could include:

• allowing flexibility over an employee’s start or finish times,
• providing a fan, or
• allowing working from home.

Menopause employer guidance

Employers need to be aware that:

• menopause symptoms may be protected from direct and indirect discrimination, as well as harassment and victimisation, on the grounds of age and sex.
• they have a legal obligation under health and safety laws to conduct an assessment of workplace risks, which should take into account the risks to menopausal women.

The EHRC also recommends the following:

• flexibility around start and end times should be considered to support women, particularly if their sleep has been disrupted.
• working from home should be allowed where possible.
• menopause-related absence should be recorded separately from other types of absence – disciplinary action resulting from menopause-related absence could be considered unlawful.
• open conversations about menopause should be encouraged and involve all workers, not just managers and menopausal women, which could be done through training or “lunch and learn” sessions, as well as conversations in less formal settings.
• workplace environment, such as room temperature and ventilation, should be considered.
• rest areas or temperature-controlled areas should be introduced where possible, and uniform requirements should be relaxed to avoid any disadvantaging of menopausal women.

In a nutshell:

The EHRC guidance published today will assist employers to do the following:

• put support mechanisms in place to retain and safeguard the wellbeing of some of their key members of staff, typically at the peak of their career – and consequently reduce the risk of claims.
• educate their workforce about menopause related issues and have proper policies in place that deal with banter, victimisation and discrimination in all its guises.

How will tribunals deal with discrimination claims on grounds of menopause?

• A CFO at a fintech company recently won an age and sex discrimination claim after she was described by her CEO as menopausal.
• A former Direct Line employee won her claim after her employer failed to make reasonable adjustments when she began experiencing menopause-related concentration issues.

For advice or a menopause policy for your staff handbook, contact nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44(0)7917 878384

February 15

Key changes to holiday pay in 2024

The most significant changes have been made to holiday pay rules for some time as the UK seeks to enshrine in UK law many of the principles introduced by the EU.

The headline changes which will take effect for holiday years commencing from 1 April 2024 onwards include:

• re-introducing rolled-up holiday pay for irregular hours and part-year workers using the 12.07% of hours worked calculation method;

• changes to the definition of a week’s pay for holiday pay calculations;

• changes to carry over of holiday rules.

Rolled-up holiday pay is to be allowed – for some….

• The term “rolled-up” holiday pay refers to the practice of paying an employee’s holiday pay at the same time as basic pay (i.e. “rolling” the two payments together).

• The new laws allow rolled-up holiday pay for holiday years from 1 April 2024, (up to a maximum of 28 days per year) as long as:

– the worker counts as an irregular hours or part-year worker;

– holiday pay is calculated at 12.07% of all pay for work done;

– the extra 12.07% is paid at the same time as pay for the work done;

– the holiday pay is itemised separately on the payslip.

There are some special rules for calculating rolled-up holiday pay if the worker is on sick leave or family leave – namely, where an individual has periods of absence through the year (for example on maternity or sick leave) and therefore the 12.07% method is not workable, their holiday accrual will instead need to be calculated over a 52 week reference period.

This approach will not be mandatory, but if you are an employer struggling with how to calculate holiday entitlement and pay for workers whose hours are irregular or occasional, then this could be a welcome development. Many such workers are not obliged to work any particular days, making it tricky to earmark any day as a holiday and make the correct payment.

NOTE:
• The new system means that you can manage holidays by simply paying an extra 12.07% pay supplement.
• When the worker actually takes holiday, they do not get paid extra holiday pay because they have already had it rolled up in their pay.

Potential pitfalls

There are a few potential drawbacks with rolled-up holiday pay:

• Rolled-up holiday pay is only available for people working on a part-year or irregular hours basis. So, if you do choose to offer rolled-up holiday pay, you must ensure that the worker is eligible first.

• The rolled-up holiday pay option doesn’t allow scope for distinguishing between different types of leave and paying them at different rates. The supplement must be paid on all earnings. There may be some situations in which that could make holiday more expensive.

• A word of caution about working time. Rolled up holiday pay doesn’t mean that workers can start working 52 weeks of the year, without taking any holidays. The onus is still on you to make sure they have at least 5.6 weeks off. The difference is just that, when they do take that time off, it would be unpaid as holiday pay has been accounted for in the rolled up holiday pay supplement.

Changes to the definition of a week’s pay for holiday pay

The other area of contention for holiday pay for some time has been whether holiday pay should include regular overtime, commission, bonuses, call out payments or just basic pay.

EU law concluded that holiday pay should not be calculated on basic pay only. Instead it should be calculated on the normal pay that the employee actually received. Therefore, the new rules aim to restate and codify these principles.

Please NOTE: Technically, employees in the UK have two separate holiday entitlements – four weeks’ leave based on EU law and an extra 1.6 weeks based on UK law, In practice employers view their employees as simply having 5.6 weeks of holiday each year but the distinction is important to note when viewing the new regulations.

Under the new rules, there will be two calculation methods although employers can adopt the more generous method for both types of leave:

• Holiday pay for the first 4 weeks of statutory holiday pay (and all holiday pay paid to irregular hours and part-year workers) must be calculated based on new “normal remuneration” provisions. which should include:

– Payments including commission payments which are intrinsically linked to the performance of tasks which the worker is obliged to carry out under their contract;

– Payments for professional or personal status relating to length of service, seniority or professional qualifications;

– Payments such as overtime payments, which have been regularly paid to a worker in the 52 weeks preceding the calculation date.

• The remaining 1.6 weeks statutory holiday can be paid at ‘basic’ pay level.

The reality is that employers will likely adopt the same policy for all holiday pay – but that same policy must be the more generous of the two.

Changes to the right to carry over holiday from one year to the next

The rights in relation to carry over of leave from one year to the next have also been codified in UK law.

• Where an employee is unable to take holiday due to family leave or sickness absence : they can carry over their holiday entitlement for a maximum period of 18 months after the holiday year in which it was accrued.

• Where an employee has not been able to take paid holiday in the correct holiday year because:

– their worker status has been denied by the employer (i.e. the employer has incorrectly classed them as self-employed); or

– their employer has failed to give them reasonable opportunity to take leave or encourage them to do so; or

– their employer has failed to tell the worker that if they don’t take the leave it will be lost;

they will be entitled to carry over 4 weeks’ holiday per year and every year unless and until the employer corrects the failing.

In practice this means it is more important than ever that employers must:
• ensure that they accurately assess the status of all individuals working for the company;
• ensure that they have systems and documents in place communicating the right to take holiday, encouraging employees to access the same throughout the year and explaining that holiday will be lost if not taken.

What should employers do now:

Employers should start reviewing their current approach to holidays against this new system:

• If you have populations of workers who are paid overtime, commission, or allowances etc then double check that this is being factored into their holiday pay correctly.

• If you want to pay holiday at different rates then you’ll need a system for identifying which type of holidays are which and setting out clearly, in a policy, that holidays are used up in a particular order.

• If you have workers who count as irregular hours or part-year workers, then review your approach against the new accrue-as-go system.

• Remind workers to use up their holiday entitlement and give them sufficient opportunity to do so.

• Update contracts and policies as necessary.

For advice and assistance please email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 (0)7917878384

January 22

New employment laws for 2024

This year will see a series of legislative changes that will have ramifications for workers, employees and employers. It is shaping up to be a busy year for new employment laws. The changes in policy cover:

• holiday pay
• flexible working
• greater protection for those pregnant or returning from maternity leave
• new rights for those with caring responsibilities
• duty on employers to prevent sexual harassment.

Holidays

From 1 April 2024, new laws on holiday entitlement and pay come into effect, requiring employers to maintain full normal pay levels for at least four weeks of an individual’s holiday entitlement and allowing workers to carry forward unused holiday entitlement in certain circumstances. If you pay overtime, commission or other allowances to your workers, you should check that you are factoring this into their holiday pay as required. You should also make sure that you are reminding workers about the need to use up their holiday entitlement within the holiday year.

The headline changes include:

1. re-introducing rolled-up holiday pay for irregular hours and part-year workers;
2. re-introducing the 12.07% of hours worked calculation method for irregular hours and part-year workers;
3. changes to the definition of a week’s pay for holiday pay calculations;
4. changes to carry over of holiday rules.

*** Next month the newsletter will focus in more detail on the new laws on holidays ***

Flexible working

On 6 April 2024, workers will be able to ask for flexible working from day 1 of employment (instead of having to complete 6 months of employment before putting in a request). It may raise the prominence of the right to request flexible working at a time when some employers are taking a tougher approach to office attendance, but ultimately the changes are limited: whether to accept or decline a request remains in the hands of the employer.

Carer’s leave

From 6 April 2024, the new right to carer’s leave also comes into effect. From this date, employees will have a new statutory right to a week’s unpaid leave to care for a dependent. Whatever the size or nature of your business, you are likely to employ some workers with caring responsibilities even if they have not previously disclosed that they are a carer. You will need to think about updating or creating new policies, introduce a system of record-keeping to track the number of days taken and ensure that people managers are aware of this new right.

Returners from family friendly leave

From 6 April 2024, employees who are pregnant or returning from maternity, adoption or shared parental leave will gain priority status for redeployment opportunities in a redundancy situation. The changes will materially increase the numbers of employees with protection (for example, fathers taking just 6 weeks’ of shared parental leave will become eligible for 18 months of protection). If you are considering or planning restructuring in 2024, you will need to think through the implications of the new protections and the practical issues that may arise.

Paternity leave

Also in April 2024, the government is expected to make minor changes to paternity leave. This will allow paternity leave to be taken at any time in the first year and to be split up into two separate blocks of one week. The current six-month qualifying period, overall limit of two weeks’ leave and low levels of statutory payment will continue, however, so this does not make paternity leave into a much bigger right.

Looking ahead to the remainder of the year, there continues to be a lot of legislative change.

Fair distribution of tips

The long-awaited new law on the fair distribution of tips seems likely to come into effect on 1 July 2024, impacting employers in the hospitality sector.

Right to request a predictable working pattern

A new statutory right to request a predictable working pattern is also due to come into force in around September 2024 giving all workers the right to request a more predictable contract and requiring employers to put new processes in place for handling those requests. While the new right appears to apply to a wide range of workers, employers will retain the right to reject requests.

Proactive steps to prevent sexual harassment

On 26 October 2024, the Worker Protection Act comes into effect, requiring employers to take proactive steps to prevent their employees from being sexually harassed at work. Ahead of the October commencement date, the Equality and Human Rights Commission will be publishing new guidance or a new Code of Practice on what proactive steps employers are expected to take. What the EHRC say (whether in new guidance or a new Code) will be critical in setting the bar for employers. That bar has gone up in a post #metoo world, so all employers need to pay close attention to this development.

Data Protection and Digital Information

At some point during 2024, the government is expected to pass its Data Protection and Digital Information Bill, which aims to maintain data protection adequacy with the EU while relaxing a few areas that may benefit employers, including a less expansive definition of personal data and a new ability to ignore vexatious or excessive data subject access requests.

Neonatal leave

A new right to neonatal leave is also on the way providing parents with a right to 12 weeks’ leave and pay when their baby requires neonatal care in addition to existing parental leave entitlements. The government has indicated that this will not take effect until April 2025 but it could potentially happen sooner.

Potential new laws that are only at the moment being talked about….

• a statutory right to time off for fertility treatment
• a capping to the length of post-employment non-compete clauses at three months

What about the impact of a Labour victory in 2024 on employment laws?

Headline proposals include:

• a right not to be unfairly dismissed from the first day of employment (scrapping the current two-year qualifying period);
• a move to a simple two-part framework for employment status (abolishing the three categories we have now);
• a ban on zero-hours contracts;
• strengthened trade union rights including a right of entry to workplaces;
• further strengthening of harassment laws; and
• the introduction of ethnicity and disability pay gap reporting.

In summary:

2024 looks set to be a year of significant change to employment legislation. This comes as employers are facing a range of other employment challenges, including:

• enforcing stricter return to office policies,
• managing conflicting viewpoints amid the so-called ‘culture wars’
• trying to stay on top of the developments in AI.

For assistance to create new, or amend existing, policies to reflect the new changes that are coming down the line this year please email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 87838

NEWER OLDER 1 2 3 4 5 … 19 20