March 26

How can employers get the balance right between responding to formal requests to work from home and mandating office attendance?

More than five years after the start of the COVID pandemic, “return to office” approaches are evolving. Increasingly, large employers in the UK are requiring a full return to office. For example, companies such as Amazon have recently asked staff to return to the office full time. Other employers may not require full-time office attendance, but they are adjusting their hybrid working arrangements, increasing the number of days which must be spent in the office.

Having enjoyed the autonomy and flexibility of remote work during the pandemic, employees are now hesitant to give it up. Remote working is fiercely valued by employees with numerous surveys showing it to be more important to employees than pay. Employees are continuing to strongly resist changes to hybrid working arrangements – most commonly by submitting formal requests for remote working.

But the upward trend of remote working requests isn’t just about return to office mandates. The pandemic has reframed home working as a viable solution to a whole range of predicaments from health concerns to caregiving or relocations. And this can often be a driver behind any requests to continue working from home.

So, as the world of work is being reshaped, employers will need to be ready to respond to an increase in requests to work from home.

Your workforce strategy

When settling on a workforce strategy relating to remote working, employers will need to consider how it fits in with their broader culture and values. While some organisations are worried about the impact on culture and collaboration of too much working from home, employers in sectors where remote working isn’t an option are worried about losing employees to more remote-friendly sectors. The impact of increased office attendance on both retention and recruitment can be crucial in some industries.

Will the Employment Rights Bill have any impact?

Last year, the former Conservative government made requesting flexible working a “day 1” right, removing the need for 26 weeks’ continuous service. Labour supported that plan but committed to go further by making flexible working the “default”.

The Employment Rights Bill includes two key changes:

• an employer can only refuse a flexible working request if it is reasonable for them to do so.
• an employer must state the ground for refusal and explain why it is reasonable to refuse the request on those grounds.

This is not a radical change to the existing flexible working regime and the changes arguably fall short of making flexible working “the default”. However, the need to demonstrate the “reasonableness” of any refusal will perhaps make it harder for employers to refuse requests outright.

Any changes are unlikely to come into force until 2026. Employers who are currently engaged in return to office debates may wish to prioritise discussions this year so that any remote working requests made in response can be considered under the current regime.

Having said that, this is unlikely to totally remove this issue for employers. Since April 2024, employees are able to make two flexible working requests a year. The upcoming strengthening of the law could therefore result in employees repeating requests if they felt a previous refusal was unreasonable.

Responding to requests to work from home

A tangible way employees can resist a return to office mandate is by making a request to work from home – either full time or, perhaps, just a day or two less than what their employer requires.

Do employees have a right to work from home?

Not unless this is part of the terms of their employment contract.

During the pandemic, some employers made changes to their standard employment contracts to include remote working as the default, at least for new starters. If remote working is agreed as part of the employment contract, it can be difficult to row back from. It’s not impossible to change, but it would involve a formal process to change terms.

Most employees are simply working remotely on an informal basis, as a continuance of the temporary arrangements put in place during the pandemic without any formalised change to their underlying employment contracts. If remote working was only ever allowed on a temporary or concessional basis, then employers can generally enforce the contractual wording about office-based working as long as an appropriate process is followed (and bearing in mind that employees might push back by putting in a request to work remotely).

In some cases, however, the terms of the employment contract are unclear or have arguably been altered by subsequent communications about working arrangements since the lifting of pandemic restrictions.

Can employees put in a request to work from home?

Employees have a statutory right to request flexible working. The law does not specifically relate to home working but remote working is one of the flexible working arrangements that can be applied for.

If making a flexible working request under the statutory framework, employees are supposed to say that they are doing so. Employers are not completely free to ignore requests outside the statutory framework, especially if that would risk discrimination. A statutory request, however, triggers the employer’s obligation to follow the statutory process and associated timescales. In practice, many employers have their own flexible working policies which build in compliance with the statutory framework.

If an employee puts in a statutory flexible working request for remote working, can we say no?

Employers can only say no to a request on the basis of one or more of eight permitted business reasons, including detrimental impact on quality or performance.

There’s no appeal-level case law on remote working requests after the pandemic, but there are a handful of interesting employment tribunal decisions which look at possible reasons for fairly refusing home working requests:

• in one of the first decisions grappling with this topic last year, Wilson v FCA, the tribunal unanimously agreed that the employer’s concern about the negative impact of remote working on the performance of a senior manager were well founded, confirming the drawbacks of technology when it comes to rapid discussions and non-verbal communication etc.

• in Mr Corrigan v The Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman, the tribunal found that concerns around detrimental impact on workforce cohesion, collegiality and the training and retention of new starters were all valid.

• in Mr H Morsing v Howden Joinery Group plc, the tribunal agreed that the line manager had genuine concerns about a request to work from home for 3 days, rather than 2, that it would detrimentally impact quality and an ability to meet customer demand. Despite having worked from home for 3 days during the pandemic, the line manager believed being in the office more frequently would improve response times and team collaboration.

These are early signals from the tribunals but they tend to support the view that employers can legitimately refuse statutory requests for remote working, but only if this comes after proper consideration and a clear rationale. In all these cases, the employers had given the requests serious and careful consideration. For example, in Wilson, the Tribunal noted that the manager had carefully analysed the factors for refusing the request with a detailed analysis of the employee’s duties. In Corrigan, the Tribunal commented that the employer’s decision was not “off the cuff” and that extensive research had been undertaken.

What are the consequences of unlawfully rejecting a statutory remote working request?

Employees can bring an employment tribunal claim under the statutory flexible working framework if:
• the request is refused for other reasons;
• a refusal is based on incorrect facts;
• the request was not dealt with in a reasonable manner; or
• the employer failed to meet the statutory deadlines and process requirements.

Compensation for not complying with the statutory flexible working regime is limited to a maximum of eight weeks’ pay. This is not set to change under the Employment Rights Bill.

Higher compensation is available only if the employee successfully brings another claim such as discrimination.

When is it sex discrimination to say no to home working requests for childcare reasons?

Any policy which disadvantages people with childcare responsibilities will arguably have a disproportionate impact on women, who still shoulder most of the childcare responsibilities in the UK.

If the employee wants remote working because the hours are then easier to juggle with childminder or school drop-off and collection times, an employer will find it difficult to reasonably refuse. Research shows that professional women are more likely to work full-time where hybrid and remote working are standard practice, suggesting that policies requiring office attendance do have a disproportionate disadvantageous impact on women and that women are more likely to request part-time hours if remote working is refused.

If tribunals can be persuaded that women are disadvantaged by a policy on office attendance, then:

• employers will need to be ready to justify their policy as a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. This is a higher hurdle to get over than the “correct facts” or “dealing with the request in a reasonable manner” test under the statutory flexible working regime. Ideally, employers would have evidence to support assertions about why their office attendance policy is justified.

• it’s not just women who can make a claim. Men facing the same childcare obstacles can now also claim discrimination.

So, in summary, rejecting remote working requests which are made for childcare reasons carries a discrimination risk. On the other hand, an environment in which mothers of small children generally work remotely while everyone else is in the office also carries longer term DEI risks.

Could home working be a reasonable adjustment?

Employers have a duty to make reasonable adjustments for employees who qualify as disabled under the Equality Act 2010. We now routinely see “work from home” recommended by occupational health practitioners as a (temporary or permanent) reasonable adjustment. Although in some cases that assessment can be questioned, it is often the case that working from home will alleviate the employee’s problems and, as remote working becomes more of a possibility, we can expect it to be increasingly asked for as a reasonable adjustment.

Anecdotally, significant numbers of employees are struggling to return to the office for reasons connected with physical or mental conditions, including neurodivergence, anxiety and long Covid, which may not be diagnosed. Conversations about how employees are managing the return to office may surface these health issues and lead on to questions about reasonable adjustments and/or a request for a formalised remote working arrangement.

More significantly, making adjustments might mean making exceptions to your normal office attendance policy. The duty to make reasonable adjustments involves going above and beyond what you would do for non-disabled employees. A number of recent tribunal decisions have illustrated this:

• in Mr D Sanders v Department for Education, the tribunal found that a requirement to work from the office for three days each week put the claimant at a substantial disadvantage when his symptoms were exacerbated.

• in MacFarlane v HMRC, the majority found that the organisation had failed to balance its focus on getting everyone back to the office against the employee’s personal health concerns and caring responsibilities.

These decisions highlight the need for employers to ensure any flexible working request is considered in light of an employee’s health. The key challenge for employers often lies in getting occupational health advice on whether remote working really is a reasonable adjustment.

What if the employee cites caring responsibilities?

Employees with caring responsibilities for elderly or disabled adults are under the spotlight currently, with the introduction of a new right to carer’s leave in April 2024. Caring responsibilities are increasingly cited by employees as a reason for wanting remote working.

There are ongoing calls to make caring a protected characteristic in its own right, but it is not currently recognised as one. If the employee is looking after someone who is elderly or disabled, they are protected against direct discrimination based on being ‘associated’ with someone who is protected because of age or disability. This does not, however, extend to indirect discrimination.

That said, it remains arguable that women shoulder most of the adult care (as well as childcare) burden, meaning that carers may be able to challenge unjustified office attendance policies as amounting to indirect sex discrimination. For this reason, employers should be mindful of the potential discrimination risk if refusing remote working requests from carers.

Do pregnant employees have the right to remote working?

The law requires employers to assess the workplace risks posed to pregnant women and make alterations to working conditions or hours if needed. We increasingly see pregnant employees with significant (typically London-based) commutes asking for remote working. It’s arguable that an employer’s health and safety duties do not extend to risks associated with the commute (as opposed to the workplace itself) but nonetheless it is generally advisable to make adjustments where possible. Employees do not generally make these requests within the statutory flexible working regime and they are generally best dealt with outside of it not least because very quick decisions are often needed and the adjustments are only very temporary.

Top tips when handling home working requests

When considering requests to work from home against the backdrop of evolving return to office strategies, it’s important not to adopt a blanket approach and to consider each request carefully. Our top tips include:

• don’t trip up over process. Employees have a right to put in statutory requests to work remotely and this triggers a requirement to follow the correct process within the required deadlines.

• explore the reasons behind any request for remote working. Under the statutory flexible working regime, employees are not obliged to say why they are making their request. But to manage the request appropriately, employers will want to know. This is partly to help with exploring compromises and partly to help ensure that you manage the request without discrimination.

• having a clear rationale for office attendance that is shared, articulated and reviewed is important. Otherwise there is the risk of managers making inconsistent decisions or basing decisions on incorrect facts.

• your rationale will need to stand up to scrutiny. Under the flexible working regime, that scrutiny is currently relatively limited (other than in, say, an indirect sex discrimination claim where there is a higher test for objective justification). But this does seem likely to change once the Bill comes into force.

• even if your office attendance policy is legally justifiable, the statutory flexible working regime now puts a greater emphasis on compromises and you will still need to assess each request on an individual basis. You also may need to make exceptions to your policy to allow disabled or pregnant employees to work remotely in some instances.

• when considering changes to office attendance, start gathering data to support any hybrid or office working policy which would support the refusal of any request to work from home more.

• ultimately, employees place such a high value on remote working that employers need to consider their policies as part of their overall workforce strategy and value proposition.

For advice contact nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or +44 7917 878384

March 10

Menopause related tribunal claims have trebled in the last two years….

To say menopause symptoms can have a significant impact on women at work is an understatement. New guidance was published a year ago – if menopause symptoms amount to a disability under the Equality Act 2010 employers will be under a legal obligation to make reasonable adjustments – a failure to do so can result in disability discrimination.

With nearly 4 million women aged 44-55 employed in the UK and women over 50 representing a significant and growing percentage of the workforce, there are few workplaces where menopause is not being experienced by workers.

Increase in menopause-related tribunal claims

Data from HM Courts & Tribunal Service showed 64 cases cited the menopause in 2022, compared to 204 last year in 2024. The claims concerned included disability, sex and age discrimination, as well as constructive and unfair dismissal.

Disability discrimination cases now account for one in four of total claims referred to ACAS.

Menopause and the law

Plans outlined in the Employment Rights Bill could result in many more menopause-related claims. Specifically, the move to make unfair dismissal a day-one right, combined with the requirement for organisations to publish equality plans incorporating a commitment to supporting staff experiencing menopause, may lead to a further increase in cases.

The increase in disability discrimination cases referred to ACAS highlights a rising trend in mental health problems, which includes menopause-related conditions like depression, stress and anxiety, being recognised as disabilities.

Symptoms and awareness

Menopause can cause:
• more than 30 frequently reported symptoms, all of which can impact an employee’s comfort, productivity and workplace relationships
• cognitive issues like memory lapses, brain fog, concentration difficulties, and reduced confidence, which can be seen as performance problems
• physical symptoms including hot flushes, fatigue, sleep disturbances, joint pain and headaches.

Although awareness of mental health and other disabilities has grown in the workplace, the extent to which menopause can constitute a disability is still a major blind spot for many employers.

At a time when employers are putting more pressure on employees to return to the office, employees experiencing menopause symptoms may benefit from home working for the following reasons:

• avoiding a stressful commute reduces exhaustion and allows for better time management.
• a flexible schedule means she can adjust her working hours around symptoms, such as working during peak energy times.
• reduced workplace stress because there is a pressure to ‘push through’ symptoms in a traditional office setting which is obviously absent when working from home.

Disability and the law

The phrase ‘not all disabilities are visible’ only entered popular usage recently but highlights the common misconception that many still hold when thinking of a disability.

While dementia and schizophrenia are widely recognised as serious mental disorders, there is increasing acceptance that less defined conditions such as depression and anxiety, which can be symptoms of menopause, can also be considered disabilities for the purposes of employment law.

A condition must have a ‘substantial and long-term adverse effect’ on an individual to qualify as a disability, but this is a highly subjective test, which can only be determined on a case-by-case basis and is open to widely differing interpretations. This leaves the door open for unsympathetic employers dismissing genuine menopausal symptoms, with the ensuing risk of employment tribunal claims as a result.

Employer action

The increase in disability discrimination cases linked to menopause indicates a need for improved training for HR professionals and line managers in handling and supporting employees affected by menopause. Many managers likely lack sufficient understanding of the symptoms employees might face and aren’t creating a supportive environment that encourages open discussions about their experiences and potential improvements to their work conditions and workloads. Additionally, managers need guidance on managing any disclosures employees may make.

The increase in claims involving menopause highlights the need for organisations to take action to prevent them facing the same fate. HR and line managers will find it easier to stay on the right side of the law if protocols are established and followed. This involves regularly reviewing and updating health and wellbeing policies and ensuring that knowledge and skills are kept up to date, particularly in areas such as menopause where cultural norms are rapidly evolving.

Employers aiming to better support staff experiencing menopause should:

• implement a menopause policy,
• offer flexible working options (including remote work, adjusted start/end times, or flexibility based on the employee’s daily condition),
• adjust temperature control,
• provide access to quiet areas, and
• revise absence management or performance management policies to consider the effects of menopause on employees.

Summary

The menopause tends to affect more experienced employees and so employers risk losing their top talent if they do not support them in a way that ensures that they can continue working.

For advice email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

Copyright © 2025 GoodHR Ltd All rights reserved.
Registered in England no. 8408047

www.goodhr.co.uk
nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk
Tel. 44(0)7917 878384

unsubscribe from this list update subscription preferences

February 5

Are you ready for the new law on neonatal leave and pay?

It has been confirmed that neonatal leave and pay will come into force from 6 April 2025, providing parents with a right to up to 12 weeks’ leave and pay when their baby requires neonatal care.

The aims of the new rights are to allow parents dedicated time to spend with their baby while they are receiving medical care without that eating into their maternity, paternity or shared parental leave.

Who is eligible?

Neonatal care leave (‘NCL’) is intended to support employees whose baby is receiving, or has received, neonatal care. In line with changes made to other forms of family leave in the Employment Rights Bill, employees can benefit from NCL from day one of their employment.

At the birth of the baby, the employee must be one of:

• the baby’s parents,
• the baby’s intended parents (applicable to surrogacy),
• partner to the baby’s mother (who are unrelated and living with them in an enduring family relationship) with the expectation they will have responsibility for raising the child.

If adopting, similar principles as above apply.

To qualify for NCL, the baby must be born on or after 6 April 2025.

NCL must be taken to provide care for the baby. In the very sad circumstances where the baby dies after NCL has been accrued, employees are still able to take the leave as this care requirement is disapplied.

What counts as “neonatal care”?

Neonatal care must have taken place or begun within the first 28 days of birth and care must continue for a period of at least seven continuous days.

There are three narrow categories of medical care which will count as “neonatal care”:

1. any medical care received in a hospital;

2. medical care received elsewhere following discharge from hospital. Such care must be under the direction of a consultant and includes ongoing monitoring and visits to the child by healthcare professionals; or

3. palliative or end of life care.

How much leave?

The length of NCL will be dependent on how long the baby receives neonatal care but is capped at a maximum of 12 weeks. Parents will be able to take one week of leave in respect of each week the baby receives neonatal care without interruption. The week begins on the day after care started.

For parents of twins or other multiple births, neonatal leave cannot be claimed in respect of babies who are receiving care at the same time. For example, if both twins were to receive care for a period of 6 weeks, the parents would only be entitled to six weeks of leave. The maximum amount of leave remains 12 weeks.

When can the leave be taken?

Any leave must be taken within 68 weeks of the baby’s birth (or placement or entry to Great Britain in the event of adoption). The basic idea of NCL is that it will be tagged onto the end of the employee’s family leave. This is because an employee whose baby is admitted for neonatal care is highly likely to be on some other family leave at that time – typically maternity or paternity leave. The idea is then that they would be able to take NCL at the end of their planned family leave, so that the time their baby spent in neonatal care is compensated for.

However, the regime also needs to cater for those emergency situations when the employee isn’t already on leave whilst the baby is in neonatal care. This is most likely to be because a father or partner’s paternity leave has run out while the baby is still in hospital.

As a result of this effort to provide flexibility and reduced notice requirements, there is a distinction between the time the leave is used, referred to as tier 1 or tier 2 periods.

If NCL is taken whilst the baby is receiving care (and up to a week post discharge), this will be classed as a tier 1 period. Tier 1 leave can be taken in non-continuous blocks of a minimum of one week at a time.

All other leave falls within the tier 2 period and must be taken in one continuous block.

What are the notice requirements?

In line with other parental leave, employees are expected to provide notice of their intention to take NCL stating:

• their name
• the baby’s date of birth (or date of placement/entry to Great Britain if adopting)
• the start date or dates of neonatal care
• the date neonatal care ended (if applicable)
• the date on which the employee wants to take the leave
• the number of weeks of NCL the notice is being given for
• that the leave is being taken to care for the baby
• confirmation that the employee is eligible to take the leave due to their relationship with the baby

The required length of notice differs depending on when the leave is taken. However, employers should note that the employer and employee can agree to mutually waive any notice requirements.

How much pay?

The right to receive statutory neonatal care pay (‘SNCP’) requires 26 weeks of service and earnings on average of at least £123 a week. This mirrors the entitlement to maternity and shared parental leave pay.

During NCL

As with other family leave entitlements, employees will remain entitled to the same terms and conditions of employment with the exception of pay. There are also similar rules around when an employee will be entitled to return to their original role, which will always be the case for a single period of NCL.

Employees who have taken six continuous weeks of NCL also benefit from the extended redundancy protection rights (if these do not already apply via maternity, adoption or paternity leave), with the right to be offered a suitable alternative vacancy applying from the day after the employee has taken six consecutive weeks of leave and ending on the day after the child turns 18 months old.

Employees will also be protected from detriment and dismissal for exercising their right to take NCL. Dismissal of an employee for a reason connected with their taking NCL will be automatically unfair.

Employer considerations

Now that we know the detail of how NCL will work, there are some important considerations for employers to think about:

• Timing: an employee will generally take NCL at the end of their other parental leave entitlement (unless interrupted). Whilst the underlying intention is to extend the overall period of leave that can be taken, employers may find that some eligible employees choose to end their maternity leave once statutory maternity pay ends at 39 weeks and then move to NCL and SNCP for 12 weeks. This would allow for almost a whole year of paid leave (albeit at statutory rates for employers who do not enhance).
• Notice: there is complexity in determining what level of notice will apply and whether the employee falls within tier 1 or tier 2. As employers have the option of waiving notice requirements, many employers may choose to do so in practice, particularly for employees who are not taking/have already taken other forms of leave.
• Policies: employers will need to have a clear policy setting out the statutory right to leave and pay, as well as any enhanced rights. If an employer offers enhanced family leave, it will be necessary to think through the impact of NCL on any of these enhancements.
• Redundancy: employers will need to add employees taking NCL of over six weeks to the groups of employees who will be entitled to priority status in the event of a redundancy. As the protection continues until the child turns 18 months, it will be important to consider tracking employees who take this type of leave in the same way as other types of parental leave.
• Data privacy: details of the baby’s medical conditions are private under data protection legislation. The employee’s wishes should be observed in relation to sharing information with colleagues about the reason and nature of the leave they are taking.
• Absence management: effects of traumatic birth or a baby spending time in a neonatal intensive care unit could manifest themselves both physically and mentally, possibly resulting in a long-term condition or illness. Employers should be mindful of this in the event of a change in an employee’s performance, behaviour or absence. Approach requests for time off or increased sickness leave carefully, bearing in mind the potential disability discrimination risks.

For advice and/or a Neonatal Leave and Pay policy for your staff handbook please email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

January 7

Employment law changes in 2025….

Happy new year!

The Employment Rights Bill 2024 (the Bill) received a lot of attention last year….some changes are proposed for this year and some for next. The various changes are detailed below….

NATIONAL MINIMUM WAGE

Since 1st of April 2024 the National Minimum Wage rates were as follows:

• National Living Wage – £11.44
• 18 to 20 years old – £8.60
• Under 18 years old – £6.40
• Apprentice – £6.40

On the 1st of April 2025 there will be an increase in the National Minimum Wage with the new rates of:

• National Living Wage – £12.21
• 18 to 20 years old – £10.00
• Under 18 years old – £7.55
• Apprentice – £7.55

The new rates will see an increase of 6.7% for National Living Wage, whereas 18 to 20 years old rates will increase by 16.3% and under 18 years old alongside apprentice rates will see an increase by 18%.

NATIONAL INSURANCE

Alongside the announcement of increased National Minimum Wage, the Autumn 2024 Budget also announced changes to National Insurance. Subsequently, from April 2025 employer National Insurance contributions will increase from 13.8% to 15%. Additionally, employers should be aware of the secondary threshold being lowered to £5,000 from the current £9,100.

STATUTORY SICK PAY

The Bill proposes to change entitlement to Statutory Sick Pay (SSP) to a ‘day one right’, enabling employees to claim SSP in their first day of illness rather than third as it is now. Additionally, the Bill also proposes to remove the earnings limit enabling those who earn less than £123 per week to also be eligible for SSP.

Although we are not 100% certain when this change will come into force, it is very likely that it will be introduced at some point in 2025.

NEONATAL CARE (LEAVE AND PAY) ACT 2023

The Neonatal Care (Leave and Pay) Act 2023 will introduce statutory paid leave for eligible employed parents whose new-born baby is admitted to neonatal care. Eligible employed parents will be entitled to receive 12 weeks paid leave, in addition to maternity, paternity and shared parental leave. This will be available as a day one right.

Although the legislation received Royal Assent in May 2023, it will come into force in April 2025.

THE EMPLOYMENT RIGHTS BILL 2024 – CONSULTATIONS

Although the Bill reforms will not come into force until 2026, we already know that consultations will take place in 2025. Currently the Bill proposes to change the following:

• TRADE UNION – the Bill proposes to impose on employers a duty to provide employees with a written statement that they have the right to join a trade union. For new employees such notice will have to be provided alongside section 1 statement of conditions of employment. Furthermore, the Bill proposes to repeal the majority of the Trade Union Act 2016 and provide a new right of access for trade unions to workplaces.

• UNFAIR DISMISSAL – the Bill proposes to introduce the right for an employee to bring an unfair dismissal claim from the first day of their employment. This is in sharp contrast to the current position where employees must be employed for at least two years before they can bring an unfair dismissal claim.

• ZERO HOURS – the Bill proposes to amend zero hours contracts, introducing a right to guaranteed hours which would reflect the hours regularly worked by an employee. An employer would be legally required to make an offer of guaranteed hours to their employee; however, an employee may choose to remain on zero-hour contract if they wish.

• FLEXIBLE WORKING – although flexible working is already a day one right as per the Employment Relations (Flexible Working) Act 2023, the Bill proposes greater flexible working arrangements rights by requiring employers to agree to flexible working requests unless they can show that it is ‘unreasonable’. Additionally, an employer must state the ground for refusal and explain why it is reasonable to refuse the request on those grounds.

• ENTITLEMENTS TO LEAVE – the Bill proposes removal of the requirement of the qualifying period of employment for paternity and parental leave giving employees the right to such benefits from day one of employment. Bereavement leave is also proposed as a day one right and the benefit is proposed to be widened beyond loss of dependents under 18 year of age.

• DISMISSAL DURING PREGNANCY AND FOLLOWING STATUTORY FAMILY LEAVE – under the Bill, greater protection will be granted to pregnant employees extending their protection from dismissal. The same protection will apply to those returning from family leave and maternity leave. Currently, that protection only applies to redundancy situations and also has its limitations, as such employees cannot be dismissed but may be moved to an alternative vacancy if one is available. Under the new proposed changes, it will be unlawful to dismiss a pregnant employee or employee within six months of their return following statutory family leave and maternity leave.

• FIRE AND REHIRE – The Bill proposes removal of Fire and Rehire practices. Currently, an employer can dismiss an employee and rehire them essentially for the same role under new terms of employment which could potentially be disadvantaged if an employee does not agree to new terms of employment for instance. Under the new rules if an employer was going to fire an employee on the grounds of refusing to accept new term of employment, that would be automatically unfair dismissal. However, the Bill also foresees an exception to this rule of financial inability of the organisation.

Consultations which will take place in 2025 will verify whether the proposed changes in the Bill, discussed above, will remain intact. In the meantime, we will keep you updated.

For any assistance email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

December 5

The Christmas party in light of the new laws on sexual harassment….

It’s the season again – many Christmas events are in the planning, and most will involve alcohol…nothing wrong with that but the lines between the professional and the personal are often blurred creating a risk for employers. More of a risk this year with the advent of the new duty on employers to take reasonable steps to prevent sexual harassment – from other employees and from third parties.

Recent legal changes have now increased the risk that employers will end up in a costly employment tribunal if bad behaviour occurs.

New sexual harassment law

The Worker Protection Act 2023 came into place on the 26th of October 2024 and states that employers have a duty to take preventative action against sexual harassment.

What this means in practice is that you need to conduct a proper risk assessment around sexual harassment towards your staff and your broader worker base because:

• employers must now take ‘reasonable steps’ to prevent sexual harassment of employees
• and this should extend to preventing harassment from third parties, including customers, clients and contractors

What this means

The new sexual harassment law does not mean that employers are legally responsible for every instance of sexual harassment in the workplace or at company events. But if the worst happens and you haven’t taken preventative measures, there’s a good chance you will be facing up to a further 25% uplift on any awards made at an employment tribunal.

It is impossible to definitively eliminate the possibility of sexual harassment taking place, and this is not what employers are expected to do. They are, however, required to take steps that are reasonable to prevent sexual harassment. What those steps amount to is objective and must be considered case by case. Factors such as the time, cost and potential disruption caused by taking the steps will be relevant when considering their reasonableness. Other factors such as an employer’s size, resources and the nature of the workplace are also relevant considerations.

Who may be responsible for bad behaviour at company events?

The new law extends a pre-existing legal principle known as ‘vicarious liability’, meaning employers may be liable for acts of discrimination, violence and sexual harassment in the workplace committed by their employees or by third parties – if preventative measures haven’t been taken.

Crucially, this includes events outside of the office, including Christmas parties.

Here are a few examples of tribunal decisions made after sexual or physical misconduct at a festive event that illustrate the reach of vicarious liability:

• an employer was held liable after a manager sexually harassed and assaulted a colleague after the company Christmas party. This was despite the fact that the assault took place after the party, at a different location

• further, an employee successful sued its employer after the Christmas party even though the incident (an assault) occurred after both parties had travelled to a hotel after the party.

• however, an employer was held not liable for an employee being injured at a Christmas party because the employer had carried out risk assessments and taken preventive measures like hiring extra security guards.

These examples show that employers can absolutely be liable when things go wrong and this even extends to events that happen after the party has ended. However, tribunals will clearly take note of measures taken by an employer to keep their teams safe.

The importance of the risk assessment in complying with the new law

Vicarious liability is nothing new: The examples in the last section all occurred before the new sexual harassment legislation came into effect. However, now employers have an even higher legal hurdle to clear.

The duty on businesses is to anticipate scenarios when workers might be subjected to sexual harassment and take reasonable action to prevent it from taking place. At the heart of this duty is a requirement for employers to effectively assess risk.

Risk assessments help identify potential harassment issues and areas of risk within the work environment. Methods include anonymous staff surveys, organisational reviews and examining historical issues. Preventing harassment is a shared responsibility across the workforce, and educating workers about acceptable behaviour is crucial in effective risk management. The main ways that employers can educate their workforce is through their policies, training and culture:

• policies: employers must have clear, comprehensive policies outlining their stance on sexual harassment. These policies should provide guidance on identifying harassment, reporting mechanisms, consequences for perpetrators and protections for those who report in good faith.
• training: tailored training is essential for compliance. Generic ‘box ticking’ harassment training is unlikely to be sufficient. Organisations should seek to provide bespoke training that is tailored and addresses industry-specific scenarios and challenges that their workers may encounter during the course of their employment. Managers and senior staff, who have greater responsibilities, may require additional training focused on risk identification.
• culture: a culture that actively combats harassment is vital. Employers should encourage reporting and demonstrate a commitment to ongoing risk assessment and review of practices, policies and training. Regular assessments indicate a proactive approach to preventing harassment.

With respect to the forthcoming Christmas party here are some important steps to help protect your employees and demonstrate compliance:

1. Risk assessment: as said, it is important to proactively identify the risk of sexual harassment at such events and take steps to mitigate it. This can include limiting the amount of alcohol on offer, not paying for after-parties, providing guidance beforehand – or any of the other policies on this list.

2. Employee and manager training: all employees need to be aware of the new sexual harassment law and be clear that their behaviour will reflect on the company. Managers should know how they should respond when issues are reported.

3. Educate clients, contractors and customers: ensure all pre-party comms are extended to clients, contractors and customers wherever possible. You could also consider putting up signs around the party venue.

4. Pre-party comms: it is also helpful to remind participants that sexual harassment is not acceptable and encourage anybody who experiences it to report it to managers. If possible, this should include clients and contractors.

Handling complaints of harassment

When harassment reports are made, they must be investigated and addressed robustly according to company policies. Failure to do so can create an environment where harassment is not taken seriously, empowering perpetrators.

The future

The new duty has raised the bar for employers, and future legal requirements may be even stricter. The Employment Rights Bill introduced by the government on 10 October 2024 has indicated that businesses will likely need to take all reasonable steps to prevent harassment in the future to prevent harassment. The bill also confirms that employers may face liability for standalone third-party sexual harassment claims from their workers. With the bar of expectation on employers growing ever higher it will be interesting to see whether festive parties or any form of out of work engagement will be encouraged in the future.

Any questions nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

December 1

Labour’s Employment Rights Bill: 12 key takeaways

Firstly, it is important to be clear that the intended employment reforms are not set to come into force until 2026. Many of my clients are contacting me saying they have been approached by organisations offering to update their documentation in light of the new reforms. However, it is important to note the following:

1. they are not yet in force.
2. they will not be in force until, probably, 2026.
3. we don’t yet know the exact detail of the reforms.

Now that the Bill has been published, it will be subject to the usual Parliamentary process with debates and amendments put forward in both the Lords and the Commons before the Bill is granted Royal Assent and becomes law.

In addition, it will require a substantial amount of consultation over the details of the secondary legislation required to implement the Bill’s provisions. This will all take time, hence the government’s confirmation that the majority of the changes will not take place before 2026.

However, it is sensible for employers to be aware of the broad remit of the changes that are due to become law. Therefore, below are the key headline changes introduced under the Bill:

1. Day-one rights

The Bill introduces ‘day one’ rights for employees to claim unfair dismissal rather than the current two- year period. This will subject to a statutory probationary period (an ‘initial period of employment’) for new hires during which time employers will be able to terminate employment without following a full process. Details of how this will work will be set out in separate Regulations and the length of the probationary period will be consulted over, but the Government is currently proposing a period of nine months.

The Bill also introduces day one rights to paternity leave, unpaid parental leave and a new statutory (paid) bereavement leave, based on the existing statutory right to two weeks’ parental bereavement leave.

2. Statutory Sick Pay (SSP)

Rights to receive SSP are amended under the Bill, removing the current three-day waiting period and meaning that SSP will be payable from the first day of absence. The existing Lower Earnings Limit (LEL) for qualifying for SSP, currently £123 per week, will also be removed. The Government will consult on the appropriate rate of SSP for those earning below the current weekly rate.

3. Flexible working

Employees will have a strengthened right to work on a flexible basis but it remains a right to request flexible working. Employers will still have the ability to refuse a flexible working pattern on the specified statutory grounds, provided it notifies the employee of the grounds for refusal and that it is reasonable to refuse on that basis.

4. Right to a stable contract

Following the government’s manifesto commitment to end “exploitative” zero-hours contracts, the Bill introduces a new right to a guaranteed-hours contract for those who work regular hours over a 12-week reference period, with provision for subsequent reference review periods if hours become regular over a longer period of time. Importantly, workers who want to remain on zero-hours contracts will be able to do so.

The Bill also provides for workers on zero and low hours contracts to be given ‘reasonable notice’ of changes in shifts or working time, with compensation for shifts cancelled or curtailed at short notice.

5. Fire and rehire

The Bill provides for ‘fire and rehire’ (dismissal and re-engagement) to be added to the list of reasons constituting an ‘automatic’ unfair dismissal other than in very limited circumstances when a business has no alternative due to financial circumstances affecting the employer’s ability to carry on the business as a going concern.

In addition, the Bill amends the existing provisions under the Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act 1992 relating to collective redundancy (affecting 20 or more employees) and the obligation to collectively consult with employees. These provisions will no longer apply to proposed redundancies at ‘one establishment’, meaning that the obligations will potentially be much more onerous for employers seeking to make redundancies over multiple workplaces.

6. Protection during pregnancy and after family leave

Pregnant women and new parents will have strengthened protections against dismissal for six months after returning to work from a period of family leave. This will be subject to separate regulations that will prevent dismissals of these employees other than in specific circumstances.

7. Increased harassment protection

Amendments to the Equality Act 2010 under the Bill will introduce express protection from third party harassment and strengthen the recently introduced employer duty to prevent sexual harassment (in force from 26 October 2024). Employers will be required to take ‘all reasonable steps’ to prevent sexual harassment, rather than ‘reasonable steps’ as currently provided. Sexual harassment will also be added to the list of protected disclosures, under existing whistleblowing provisions.

8. Action on gender pay and menopause

Under the Bill, large employers (likely 250+ employees) are required to produce action plans to address their gender pay gaps and to support employees through the menopause. Currently, these are recommended but not mandated for employers.

9. Pay

The Bill also includes powers to create a Fair Pay Agreement in the adult social care sector and reinstate the School Support Staff Negotiating Body.

The government has separately committed to remove the existing “discriminatory” NMW age bands, and the Low Pay Commission is now required to take into account the cost of living when setting the annual NMW rates.

10. Public sector contracts

The Bill reinstates the two-tier code for public sector contracts, with the aim of ensuring that employees working on outsourced contracts are offered terms and conditions no less favourable to those transferred from the public sector.

11. Trade unions

As anticipated, the Bill provides for the repeal of the Strikes (Minimum Service Levels) Act 2023. It will also bring in additional protections for trade union members and extensive measures to simplify the statutory recognition process as well as a new right of access for union officials to meet, represent, recruit and organise members in the workplace.

Employers must provide workers with a written statement of their trade union rights along with their statement of employment particulars.

12. Fair Work Agency

A new Fair Work Agency will bring together existing enforcement functions to enforce employment rights and to support employers in compliance.

Additional proposals for reform, not included in the Bill, include the following:

• employment status – the Government plans to consult on moving towards a single status of ‘worker’ and transitioning towards a two-part framework for employment status, differentiating between workers and the genuinely self-employed

• a right to switch off, under a statutory Code of Practice, to prevent employees being contacted out of hours other than in exceptional circumstances

• a review of the existing parental leave and carers’ leave systems

• a separate Bill (the Equality (Race and Disability) Bill) to introduce new mandatory ethnicity and disability pay gap reporting for large employers and extending equal pay rights to include race and disability.

I hope this allays fears that the new year is bringing in a whole raft of new employment laws! However, 2026 will be soon upon us and so careful scrutiny as the Bill goes through Parliament is essential to ensure employers are prepared for the changes. I will ensure that I pass on updates as they emerge.

Wishing you a happy end to 2024!

nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or +44 7917 878384

November 5

When can an employer use a pre-employment health check questionnaire?

In today’s fast-paced workplace, ensuring the health and well-being of employees is essential—not just for the individual, but also for the overall productivity of your business. One important tool that helps assess an individual’s fitness for a role is the pre-employment health questionnaire.

Crucially, these can only be introduced after a job has been offered. An employer cannot make a job offer subject to a satisfactory health questionnaire – retracting a job offer on the basis of knowledge of a health condition or disability would amount to discrimination.

What is a Pre-Employment Health Questionnaire?

A Pre-Employment Health Questionnaire is a simple, confidential form filled out by employees before they start a new job. Its primary purpose is to gather information about any medical conditions or disabilities that could affect their ability to perform job tasks safely and effectively and then enable the employer to make reasonable adjustments to accommodate the employee’s needs.

Why Are These Questionnaires Important?

1. Ensuring Workplace Safety
Some roles require specific physical or mental capacities. By assessing an individual’s health, post job offer, employers can ensure that employees are safe to do the job, reducing the risk of workplace accidents or illness. For example, roles that involve heavy lifting, hazardous materials, or high-stress environments may have specific requirements to ensure safety.

2. Making Reasonable Adjustments
Pre-employment health questionnaires help employers identify any reasonable accommodations an employee may need to perform their role effectively. This ensures that businesses comply with Equality Act regulations and promote an inclusive work environment. For instance, ergonomic changes or flexible working hours may be arranged for employees with back issues or chronic conditions.

3. Preventing Discrimination
It’s important to note that these questionnaires are not used to discriminate against candidates with health conditions. Instead, they help employers support prospective employees, ensuring they have the right resources to succeed in their roles from the start.

4. Promoting Long-Term Employee Wellbeing
By identifying potential health issues early, both employers and employees can take proactive steps to manage any conditions, leading to improved job satisfaction and long-term health outcomes.

What Does a Health Questionnaire Cover?

A pre-employment health questionnaire typically covers:
• general health history (e.g., pre-existing medical conditions)
• physical or mental health issues that may impact job performance
• history of workplace injuries or illnesses
• details of any medications or ongoing treatments
• any disabilities that require workplace adjustments

Confidentiality and Compliance

It’s crucial to ensure that health information collected from employees is treated with the highest confidentiality. The data must be stored securely and used solely for the purpose of assessing workplace needs in line with GDPR and data protection laws.

How Does This Benefit Employers and Employees?

For Employers, these questionnaires minimize the risk of workplace injuries and legal liabilities, while helping to create a safe and inclusive working environment. It can also lead to reduced absenteeism and improved employee retention.

For Employees, pre-employment health questionnaires provide an opportunity to have their needs addressed right from the start. It ensures they enter the workplace with the appropriate support, enhancing their job satisfaction and long-term health.

Conclusion

Pre-employment health questionnaires are a win-win for businesses and employees. They ensure that workers are fit for their roles while helping employers create safe, inclusive, and legally compliant workplaces.

If you are an employer considering integrating pre-employment health questionnaires, or an employee wondering what to expect, do email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

October 17

Have your staff used all their holiday entitlement this year?

It is important for employers to be clear on how they deal with circumstances where workers have not used all of their annual leave. One possible approach is to adopt a ‘use it or lose it’ holiday policy, but this brings wider considerations, both to avoid damaging employee relations and to ensure workers receive their full entitlement to time off work.

How many paid holidays should UK workers get?

Most workers in the UK are legally entitled to 5.6 weeks paid holiday a year. This means that those who work a 5-day week must receive at least 28 days paid annual leave. This comprises 4 weeks (20 days) derived from EU law and 1.6 weeks (8 days) from UK law, although an employer is allowed to include bank holidays and other public holidays in this.

Employers must provide workers with the statutory minimum although they can agree to give more by way of contract. In many cases, a worker’s contract of employment will provide enhanced contractual rights when it comes to paid holiday.

How does paid holiday work in the UK?

Statutory paid holidays start to accrue from day one, where employers can adopt a leave year or accrual system to work out how much leave staff should get and how this builds up.

When using a ‘leave year’, the employer should tell their staff the dates as soon as they start working, for example, a statutory leave year might run from 1 January to 31 December. This then represents the timeframe during which workers must take their paid holidays.

Where a worker starts their job part-way through a leave year, they will only be entitled to part of their total annual leave entitlement for the current year. The amount of paid holiday they will be entitled to for that year will therefore depend on how much of the year is left. Alternatively, an employer can calculate a worker’s leave based on them receiving one-twelfth of their leave each month.

Importantly, regardless of how accrued holiday is calculated, this should not be affected by a worker being on sick leave or any other form of statutory leave, such as maternity or paternity leave, shared parental leave and adoption leave.

What is a ‘use it or lose it’ holiday policy?

The basic principle of statutory annual leave entitlement is that this will be lost if it has not been used. There are some exceptions to this rule, but usually the annual leave accrued in any leave year must be used in that same year. This is important because taking time off work helps staff to get sufficient rest breaks and to keep physically and mentally healthy.

Where an employer chooses to adopt such a policy, unless they refuse to allow or make it impossible for leave to be taken, any unused accrued holiday will normally be lost at the start of a new leave year. The only other exception to the ‘use it or lose it’ rule is where the worker has been prevented from taking their full annual leave entitlement because they have been on some other form of statutory leave: sickness or family leave.

If a worker has been on long-term sick leave, they can carry over the first 20 days of their 28 day entitlement on their return to work (for up to 18 months), whilst a worker who has been prevented from taking some or all of their paid holiday due to maternity or family leave, can carry over up to one years’ statutory entitlement (5.6 weeks or 28 days) into the following year.

Importantly, however, in the recent decision of Smith v Pimlico Plumbers Ltd [2022] the Court of Appeal made it clear that in order for a worker to lose their right to paid leave in any given leave year, the following three conditions must be met:

• the worker must have been given the opportunity to take paid annual leave
• the worker must have been encouraged to take paid annual leave, and
• the worker must have been informed that the right to paid leave would be lost at the end of the leave year, if not taken during the leave year in which it was accrued.

This effectively means that, regardless of what any holiday policy states, any accrued leave will not automatically be lost – unless the employer has pro-actively brought it to the worker’s attention that this would be the case and the worker is not only given the opportunity to take paid leave but is positively encouraged to do so. In other words, the employer must have exercised all due diligence in ensuring that leave is taken in time.

Pros and cons of a ‘use it or lose it’ policy

From an employer’s perspective, and provided they follow the guidance from the Court of Appeal in Smith v Pimlico Plumbers, there are various benefits in adopting a ‘use it or lose it’ holiday policy:

• significant savings for the business.
• ability to maintain consistent staffing levels, where workers will not be permitted to accrue large chunks of carried-over leave.

However, there are also various drawbacks to not allowing staff to carry over unused leave:

• low morale and employee burnout.
• increased absenteeism.
• cost to the business.
• multiple surges in requests to take holiday at the end of the leave year.

Carrying over unused holiday into the following year – a specified amount or on discretion.

If a worker is entitled to the statutory minimum of 28 days leave, they can carry over a maximum of 8 days with the employer’s agreement. If a worker gets more than 28 days leave, the employer may also allow them to carry over any of this additional contractual entitlement. The employer should therefore decide the number of days that can be carried over into the following leave year and make provision for this in the employment contract.

Alternatively, the employer can leave the decision to carry over any unused days at its discretion, for example, on individual request and on a case-by-case basis.

Best practice for employers

When deciding what holiday policy to adopt in the workplace, economic factors are important but maintaining a happy and healthy workforce is equally as important. People are often the best assets of a business, where ensuring the physical and mental wellbeing of staff is not only a basic statutory duty imposed on employers, but will also help to increase employee engagement and to reduce absenteeism and staff turnover rates.

If a ‘use it or lose it’ policy is adopted by a business, the following best practice tips can help to ensure that this policy is fair, lawful and effective:

• set out the policy clearly within any contract of employment.
• periodically remind staff that they should be submitting requests to use any remaining annual leave entitlement before it is lost.
• ensure staff have easy access to a cloud-based or computerised system that allows them to check their leave entitlement and how much they have remaining.
• try to agree to annual leave requests where at all possible.

Importantly, if the three conditions as set out by the Court of Appeal in the case of Smith v Pimlico Plumbers are not met then the net effect is that the right to paid annual leave does not lapse and regardless of the workplace policy, that employee will be able to carry over their holiday into the next holiday year.

Holiday calculations are often challenging! For any assistance please email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

September 30

How will the new Worker Protection law on sexual harassment affect after-work drinks?

New laws, which come into force on 26 October 2024, create a legal duty for employers to ensure that they protect workers from sexual harassment in the workplace – this extends to third party sexual harassment at a work event which is an extension of the workplace.

Employers will have a “duty to take reasonable steps” to prevent sexual harassment in the workplace. Employment tribunals will be able to increase compensation by up to 25% if they find an employer has breached their duty.

The new law will likely be strengthened by an Employment Rights Bill that is set to create a duty for employers to take “all reasonable steps” to stop sexual harassment “before it starts”.

Worker Protection Act

Under the new Act organisations will be required to take all reasonable measures to prevent sexual harassment in the workplace and should therefore prepare for an overhaul of their existing anti-harassment policies.

Work-related social events obviously will not be explicitly prohibited under the Act, but employers would need to make changes to mitigate risks and ensure compliance with the new provisions.

Employers should be aware that their duty of care to their employees does not absolve once they finish work or leave the office. It is therefore imperative to ensure that professional boundaries are maintained at any work-related event, to avoid the risk of unacceptable conduct.

A strategy designed to mitigate risks could include:

• a pre-event briefing to emphasise the importance of behaving appropriately and outlining the consequences that will arise from incidents of misconduct.
• the reduction of external risk factors, such as alcohol, to prevent any impairment to professional judgement.

The effect on companies that regularly plan social events is likely to be significant. Ultimately, following the introduction of the Act, we can expect to see a redefinition of professional boundaries and alterations to existing social norms, such as office parties or post-work drinks.

What is sexual harassment?

Sexual harassment is defined by the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) as:

• “unwanted conduct of a sexual nature”
• that has the purpose or effect of “violating a worker’s dignity” or
• “creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment for that worker”.

What should employers so to prepare?

1. In order to be able to demonstrate that reasonable steps have been taken, the employer should keep records of those steps which are likely to include:

• a statement about not tolerating harassment of workers.
• a statement that makes it clear that the employer will refuse in future to deal with customers or suppliers that act in breach of their rules.

2. Conduct a risk assessment to identify and address potential risk areas within the business including:

• reviewing past incidents.
• assessing cultural problem areas.
• evaluating the impact of third-party interactions.

3. Ensure existing policies on sexual harassment are:

• comprehensive and up to date.
• establish clear and confidential reporting mechanisms for employees to report incidents of harassment.

4. Implement training on sexual harassment.

5. Provide clarity on to whom any complaints should be brought.

6. Give guidance to managers to look out for changes in behaviour and encourage one to one discussion.

7. Be alert to the fact that workers have been known to be untruthful if they think they can escape punishment highlighting that it is important, where there is no corroborating evidence (such as messages or CCTV footage) that the victim is believed, and the perpetrator is automatically suspended whilst an investigation takes place.

Summary

This marks a crucial step forward in the UK’s commitment to creating workplaces free from sexual harassment. Employers play a pivotal role in ensuring compliance and fostering a culture that promotes respect, dignity and equality for all employees. By understanding the new requirements, defining reasonable steps, facilitating straightforward claim procedures and implementing proactive measures, employers can contribute to a safer and more inclusive working environment.

For any assistance please email nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

September 9

Hidden disabilities – how to recognise and support them in the workplace….

Employers are increasingly attuned to the impact of disability in the workplace and the measures that can be taken to create an inclusive and supportive environment for all employees. However, while visible disabilities are often supported, there are many “hidden disabilities” that go unnoticed and the link between these challenges and performance and conduct issues is easily missed.

Employees may be reluctant to divulge hidden disabilities or be unaware that they have a disability for the purposes of the Equality Act 2010. Whatever the reason for their challenges remaining unrecognised, the impact can be significant. It can create legal risks and damage both to the employment relationship and to the employee’s own wellbeing.

What are hidden disabilities?

The term hidden disabilities covers a broad range of conditions that are not readily apparent to employers. Examples include:

• mental health disorders, such as anxiety and depression.
• neurodivergence, for example ASD (autism spectrum disorder), ADHD (attention deficit hyperactivity disorder), dyslexia, dyspraxia or dyscalculia.
• chronic illnesses and pain conditions, such as fibromyalgia, arthritis or endometriosis.
• chronic digestive conditions, such as Crohn’s, ulcerative colitis or celiac disease.
• sensory processing disorders.
• eating disorders.
• autoimmune disorders.

It is also important to remember that your staff may be supporting a dependant with a disability and, in this way, be suffering an unseen disability-related challenge impacting on their own physical and mental wellbeing. Discrimination on the grounds of association with a disabled person is also unlawful under the Equality Act.

The impact of hidden disabilities

Hidden disabilities can manifest in ways that can be mistakenly dealt with as a performance or conduct issues by an employer, particularly where the employer, manager or the employee themselves are not aware of how an underlying condition is affecting the employee’s ability to carry out their duties and work with their colleagues effectively.

This lack of understanding often leads to the employee being treated unfairly and missing out on the support and adjustments that would enable them to work to their full potential.

Examples of how a hidden disability can have an impact on performance or behaviour in a way that is not obviously connected include:

• a neurodivergent employee with ADHD might display poor timekeeping and a lack of attention to detail, while excelling at other aspects of their role – this might be construed as lack of organisation and carelessness in their work.

• an employee with a condition causing chronic pain may behave aggressively, or lose their temper with a colleague – this might be viewed as misconduct, but result from the stress of managing their pain effectively.

• sensory difficulties, for example being overstimulated by lighting, noise, smells or crowds might lead an employee to be irritable or withdrawn – this might be perceived as poor behaviour or lack of effort.

Risk of discrimination

Where performance or misconduct proceedings are commenced with an employee, but the issues to be addressed have arisen because of something which arises in consequence of the employee’s disability (whether hidden or not), this can be discriminatory – there is a connection between the “something” that results in performance/conduct measures and the disability.

Example: an employee was dismissed for gross misconduct following an aggressive outburst towards another employee. His behaviour was significantly influenced by his insulin-dependent diabetes and his blood sugar readings were outside the normal range in the period leading to the outburst, which would have an impact on his emotional regulation. The employee was therefore dismissed because of something arising from his disability: there was a link between the outburst and his condition and his dismissal was ruled as unfair.

Given the complex and unexpected ways hidden disabilities can affect performance and conduct, it is important for employers and managers to think carefully about:

• whether an underlying disability might be playing a part in the matter at hand.
• Whether the behaviour and lapse in judgement is uncharacteristic and therefore should provoke further consideration.

Example: a refusal to participate in particular activities at work may look like defiance or an unreasonable request to drop a particular duty; but where that refusal arises from a disability, an employer should consider whether removing a particular aspect of an employee’s duties would be a reasonable adjustment under the Equality Act.

In this case, the employee’s sickness absence for anxiety had been triggered by the employer requiring her, as part of her duties, to do something that, when previously done, had caused trauma because of specific circumstances at that time. Being told of the requirement caused a severe anxiety reaction. The employer did not remove the requirement and maintained that this was an essential element of the employee’s duties and she was ultimately dismissed for her refusal.

In practice, employers need to carefully consider any circumstances where an employee has developed a particular anxiety related to part of their role. This could be dealing with difficult clients, customers or members of the public, giving presentations, or working with a particular manager.

Neurodivergent employees may have specific anxieties related to a particular aspect of a role which should be accommodated in reasonable adjustments being made.

Where an employer is able to reasonably make a change for any employee experiencing a specific anxiety relating to part of their role, but gives no consideration to this, or dismisses an employee’s concerns, this could give rise to a successful discrimination claim or constructive dismissal.

What can employers do to address hidden disabilities?

There are some practical steps employers can take to create an environment where employees feel more confident to share challenges and bring hidden disabilities into the open.

• providing training and raising awareness is a key step for equipping managers and colleagues to recognise any warning signs and respond appropriately and supportively.
• inclusive policies with clear commitments to diversity and reasonable adjustments will also encourage good communication: sickness absence, flexible working and wellbeing policies should all be reviewed.
• leadership support is important and participation in events by leadership sends a positive message that diversity is celebrated and supported in the organisation.
• employee support groups can also give employees the confidence to share their challenges and are a valuable source of support and can role model good communication and practical solutions.

For advice please contact nicola.goodridge@goodhr.co.uk or call +44 7917 878384

NEWER OLDER 1 2 3 4 … 19 20